(1965 [CD release 7/19/89] - Richard P. Condie, director; Alexander Schriener and Frank W. Asper, Organists - Columbia ML 6177/XMS 6777/Sony XMT06777 06777)
On January 15, 1985 this record was RIAA certified as a GOLD record, with over 500,000 copies sold.

Side 1
1. Joy To The World (Anon.-Isaac Watts), 1:30
2. When Jesus Was a Little Child (Tchaikovsky), 3:22
3. Away in a Manger (Martin Luther), 3:20
4. A Boy Is Born (15th century German carol)
5. There Shall a Star from Jacob (Mendelssohn, from "Christus")
6. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel (ancient plain song)
7. Far, Far Away on Judea's Plains (J MacFarlane)
8. O Holy Night (Cantique de Noel) (Adolphe Adam)
   Side 2
9. What Child Is This? (Greensleeves)
10. Beautiful Savior (The Crusader's Hymn) (12th century air; Arr. F.M. Chrisiansen)
11. Watts Nativity Carol
12. Tell Us, Shepherd Maids (based on a French-Canadian carol)
13. The Holy City (Stephen Adam)
14. I Heard The Bells (Longfellow)
15. Silent Night (Joseph Mohr-Franz Gruber)